Judge dismisses lawsuit against 'Balanced Literacy' proponents |
Judge Richard G. Stearns, of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts, has dismissed a lawsuit against a trio of reading professors and literacy curricula. The case, brought by two parents from separate families in Massachusetts, alleged that the professors and publisher Heinemann used “deceptive and fraudulent marketing” to sell their popular reading materials. It centered on two sets of reading programs, one created by Lucy Calkins, an education professor at Teachers College, Columbia University, and the other by reading researchers Irene Fountas and Gay Su Pinnell, of Lesley University and The Ohio State University, respectively. The publishers argued that the programs were backed by research even though, the plaintiffs claimed, they omitted or diminished the role of phonics instruction, which decades of reading research has demonstrated is a key component of teaching young children how to decode print. Judge Stearns wrote: "The court cannot find defendants’ research inadequate … without delving into the merits of defendants’ approaches to literacy education."